We all have that one “trusty” kitchen tool, like a favorite plastic spatula or a cutting board that’s seen better days. It’s hard to let go. But it’s time for some tough love: your kitchen tools are not like cast-iron skillets; they don’t get better with age.
The hard truth is, a lot of that old gear isn’t just “worn in”-it’s worn out. Those scratches in your plastic cutting board are a five-star resort for bacteria. Your warped spatulas are shedding who-knows-what into your food. And that dull knife you keep using is way more dangerous than a sharp one.
If you’re clinging to items you’ve had since your first apartment, you’re not just making cooking harder; you’re making it grosser and less safe. We’ve got the list of kitchen tools experts say you need to break up with and replace right now.
Don’t miss any of CNET’s unbiased tech content and lab-based reviews. Add us as a preferred Google source on Chrome.
“Keeping your kitchen tools in good condition ensures both safety and efficiency,” says Maricel Gentile, kitchen expert and founder of cooking school Maricel’s Kitchen. “Plus, it’s the perfect excuse to explore new gadgets, and some need replacing more often than you think.”
Below you’ll find seven examples of kitchen tools that may have worn out their welcome in your kitchen.
1. Plastic cutting boards and utensils
Plastic isn’t impervious to bacteria, even if you’re regularly putting it in the dishwasher.
“Over time, knife marks can create deep grooves that are hard to clean and can harbor bacteria,” Gentile says. “Also, plastics degrade with heat and use, releasing microplastics into the food.”
If you want to avoid microplastics in your food, replace your plastic cutting board regularly.
Rebeca Mello/Getty ImagesSigns of wear and tear can indicate that it’s time for a change. “If your board is heavily scarred or stained, it’s time to replace it,” says Gentile. With other plastic tools, look for signs of discoloration, melting or warping.
2. Plastic storage containers
Kitchen expert Sylvia Fountaine of Feasting at Home says to ditch plastic storage containers outright. If you’re using them only to keep food in the fridge, it’s probably OK, but the temptation to take storage containers from the fridge to the microwave is what makes them less than ideal. When heated, these types of containers can leach various chemicals into your food. “Opt for glass storage containers with bamboo lids,” Fountaine says.
Avoid putting your plastic Tupperware in the microwave.
Kinga Krzeminska/Getty Images3. Graters, peelers and microplanes
Metal tools with sharp edges, designed to break food down into bits like shreds and zest, don’t have any of the risks associated with microplastics and are relatively easy to clean and sanitize but can overstay their utility if you’re holding on to them for too long.
“These dull over time and become less effective at shredding or zesting,” Gentile says. “If your grater starts to mash instead of grate, it’s time for a replacement. Your recipes will thank you!”
4. Can opener
Whether a handheld or electric model, your can opener is not meant for the long term for a couple of reasons.
“It will get dull over time,” says Mitzi Baum, CEO at Stop Foodborne Illness, just like the tools above that rely on a sharp edge or blade. But the can opener also has sanitary implications. “It is a kitchen utensil that does not get regularly cleaned or sanitized,” says Baum. “If it is not washed regularly, it will have food and bacteria build up on it and could contaminate other canned foods when used to open them.”
A bunker can opener.
Nelson Aguilar/CNETIf rust has also built up on your can opener, especially the blade that may come into contact with food, it’s past time to replace it.
5. Kitchen sponges
If your kitchen sponge smells, that’s a good sign it’s time to be replaced.
Javier Zayas Photography/Getty ImagesDoes your kitchen sponge smell? Do you think that’s just how kitchen sponges always are? If so, you need to hear this.
“Kitchen sponges need to be replaced regularly as sponges can support harmful bacterial growth because they are wet and sit at room temperature — a temperature that bacteria like,” Baum says.
The musty smell of kitchen sponges indicates that bacteria are growing. There is a nonwaste solution: “The sponge can be included in the dishwasher as long as (it) includes a sanitizing cycle,” Baum says. “If you do not have a dishwasher, replace your sponges regularly, especially when it begins to smell.”
6. Wooden spoons and cutting boards
If you’re holding on to any wooden utensils or boards that belonged to a previous generation, don’t. Wooden spoons and other utensils would seem to be heritage tools, because they’re difficult to break or chip, but they’re meant for a good time, not a long time.
“Wooden spoons are kitchen workhorses, but they’re also porous, which means they can absorb liquids, oils and odors and lead to bacterial buildup,” says Debra Clark, kitchen expert and founder of Bowl Me Over. “If your wooden spoon is starting to look worn, smells funky or has deep grooves, it’s time to replace it. A good rule of thumb is to replace them every year or so if they see heavy use.”
If your wooden spoon smells musty or looks worn, it’s time to replace it.
Jann Huizenga/Getty Images7. Nonstick pots and pans
If your nonstick skillet looks anything like this, it’s time to saddle yourself with a fresh pan.
David Watsky/CNETThe coating of nonstick pans is one of the biggest culprits of forever chemicals and microplastics.
“These pans are a lifesaver for quick, low-fat cooking but the coating doesn’t last forever,” Clark says. “Over time, scratches and wear can not only reduce their effectiveness but may also release tiny bits of the nonstick material into your food,” she says, which is the point where you might accidentally ingest some of it and it starts to become really harmful. “If your pan is scratched, flaking or sticking more than it should, it’s time to invest in a new one. Most nonstick pans last about three to five years with regular use.” (Nontoxic, nonstick brands that use ceramic include Caraway and Green Pan.)
8. Silicone baking equipment
Rubber and silicone, especially cheap ones, have been found to leach chemicals into food.
M Kitchen/CNETSilicone is found all over the kitchen, from rubber scrapers and oven mitts to baking mats and trays. Anything that experiences high heat, however, should get tossed.
“To be clear about silicone tools, I wouldn’t replace them often but replace them altogether with something else like stainless or enamel bakeware,” Fountaine says. “I have been reading that silicone is possibly considered ‘safe,’ but only up to 425 degrees Fahrenheit. There is very limited research on its safety, and other additives to the silicone could potentially leach into food,” she says. “Plus It is not biodegradable or recyclable, so not very eco-friendly.”
Read more: 8 Foods You Eat Daily That You Didn’t Know Are Probably Filled With Microplastics
