Owning an Apple Home: Bye bye SwitchBot
After months of living with various SwitchBot products, namely the Lock Vision Pro and garage door opener, I've finally given up and ripped all SwitchBot products from my Apple Home. Here's why.
In July, I wrote a story for the "Owning an Apple Home" column specifically on the Broken Promise of Matter. That story was directly inspired by my frustrating experience installing and using SwitchBot products in my Apple Home.
Just four months later, I've removed every SwitchBot product from Apple Home, disconnected them from power, and put them away. Things were rough at the start, but conditions began deteriorating in the last few weeks, and before anyone suggests it, before beta software or new Apple TV hardware was introduced.
Whatever the problem, as I've noted in the Lock Vision Pro review, it seems SwitchBot is at a minimum uncaring at how good the experience is using its products in Apple Home. I know it isn't the case, but the levels of errors feel almost like deliberate sabatoge, because I have no idea how products like these can ship in this condition.
Sure, the products themselves are solid, but only if you live in the SwitchBot app. I should have taken the company's shift towards AI chatbots and mascots as a warning, but SwitchBot is clearly not for me, at least not anymore.
The initial issues
When I agreed to review a smart lock from SwitchBot, I asked for a hub to ensure I could get everything working. The company sent me some of their cameras, an AI hub, the smart lock, and a separate hub device with a dial.

Devices in my home need to work well with the Apple Home app
I then purchased a garage door opener from the company assuming it would be good to stick to one set of products. They were Matter or Apple Home enabled except the cameras, so I figured it would all be fine with my Apple Home.
The AI hub let me install Home Assistant to manage the cameras and get them into Apple Home. It also featured the ability to run OpenClaw for automation.
I was too sketched out by OpenClaw to do more than install it, look at the options, then immediately delete it. The last thing I wanted was my camera feeds being analyzed by some external AI entity.
Apple Home had my trust with HomeKit Secure Video, SwitchBot did not.
The cameras added via Home Assistant wouldn't show a live feed in Apple Home. At most, I might see a new image every few hours, but I never managed to get them to actually stream except from the SwitchBot app.

I can trust Apple HomeKit Secure Video with AI analysis, not SwitchBot and OpenClaw
I installed the garage door opener, which was allegedly Matter. I assumed this meant an easy install, but I was wrong.
Instead of showing up as a garage door, the device installed itself as a SwitchBot device hub, which then added a door lock to Apple Home. Not a garage door, but a door lock, padlock icon and all.
Locking and unlocking this "lock" would open and shut the garage. I have no idea why the device didn't simply show up as a garage door as expected.
Then, once I installed the Lock Vision Pro, I realized only then that the lock didn't support Apple Home Key. It had many ways to control it, including palm vein recognition, face recognition, and thumbprint scanning.
It showed up in Apple Home, but only as a door lock without any addressable sensors. There was a door opening and closing sensor, but it wasn't surfaced in Apple Home.
At this point, I was frustrated but the products worked, more or less. These were weird quirks, but I hoped they'd still be good fits for my Apple Home.
The latest problems
Weeks go by and I slowly start to disconnect the various SwitchBot products. I abandoned the cameras almost immediately and unplugged the AI hub.

This little hub thing could control my Sony TV. Neat.
The hub with a knob was next to useless except to bounce IR signals off my Sony TV if I so desired. It just kind of hung there on the wall and felt odd given the Apple HomeView was revealed while this device existed in my home.
The garage door opener showing up as a lock and the lack of Home Key confused and frustrated my wife Natalie, but she lived with the weirdness without complaint. The garage door opened and shut, and she could get in the house, so all was well.
Then, starting in October I kept getting hit with notifications from the Lock Vision Pro "door open" and "door closed." These notifications arrived in rapid succession and seemingly had nothing to do with the real status of the door.
The SwitchBot app and Apple Home app surfaced no options for controlling these notifications. As far as Apple Home was concerned, there was no door open and close sensor in spite of the notifications.
I finally just turned the notification off on my iPhone. Then the notification started flooding my Apple TVs until I turned them off there.
Needless to say, this particular bug was infuriating. I assumed there was something weird happening somewhere to have that happen and it would be temporary.

Things just started to get buggy or just not work entirely.
I checked for an update and tried to install it, but the installation tool kept failing out, so I gave up.
Another issue in recent weeks was a degradation in authentication. I'd go to unlock the door and my fingerprint wouldn't work, the palm reading function just ignored me, and finally it would use my face.
Sure, I could have pulled out my phone, opened the Apple Home app, then tapped the lock, but these features are supposed to work. What's more, if it had Apple Home Key, I could have tapped my watch to the door to open it.
The final straw
The new Apple TV 4K arrived and I got it set up, only to have it immediately start getting flooded with "door open" and "door shut" notifications. That reminded me to check for updates again.

Home Key is not an option on the SmartBot Lock Vision Pro
I finally got the update tool to work and the lock was now up to date after a half-hour process. I had to leave the SwitchBot app open and my iPhone Duo perched near the lock for the update to install.
That night, without explanation, the SwitchBot Lock Vision Pro showed up in Apple Home as a door sensor with "door open." Tapping the icon would lock and unlock the lock without changing the icon.
Something was very broken.
An hour later, the issue resolved itself and the icon had returned. However, my faith in this product was broken.
I don't know what's going on over at SwitchBot, but I am entirely unhappy with its situation and how it integrates with Apple Home. I'm even more frustrated by the knowledge that Nanoleaf, an amazing company whose products I enjoy, was acquired by SwitchBot.
My colleague Andrew O'Hara reports he has not run into issues with SwtichBot products in his setup. Your miles may vary.

Apple Home Collection should be the blueprint on any Apple-friendly accessory going forward
Whether or not these are bugs with the software, my setup, or a broken piece of hardware, that's not the point. My problem is the overall experience of the SwitchBot ecosystem since I installed the first product.
Everything seems unoptimized for Apple Home and the app seems more and more focused on AI tools and integrations. SwitchBot clearly wants me in that app every day, not Apple's.
So, here's where I am as an Apple Home user. Apple's new strategy centers around a vertically-integrated experience that works great within the Home app and on Apple HomeView.
I'm going to embrace that strategy as my own. While not everything can be Apple-made or second-party like the Apple Home Collection, many smart home products get close.
SwitchBot products do the opposite.
I'm planning a story soon about third-party Apple Home products that ride that line between third and second-party. I've got a few device manufacturers on that list and I'm eager to find more.
Whatever the case, I've made my decision for the short term. If a smart home device can't be easily installed and managed from Apple Home, I'm not interested.
Source: Read original article
Comments ()